Wednesday 24 December 2014

Understanding Debt Service Ratios

Understanding Debt Service Ratios


One of the primary considerations in determining mortgage product suitability is an applicant’s debt service ratios.  The Mortgage Industry looks at the current income level for the applicant(s) and puts a cap on the maximum amount of money to be advanced for mortgage purposes.  There are two ratios used in the underwriting process; Gross Debt Service (GDS) and Total Debt Service (TDS).


Gross Debt Service Ratio


The GDS is determined by using the following calculation:

GDS = Principle & Interest + Taxes + Heat (PITH) + Condo Fees (if applicable) / Total Monthly Gross Income

The P & I calculation is obtained from the monthly payment for the desired interest rate and mortgage amount including any applicable mortgage insurance premiums (CMHC, Genworth, or Canada Guarantee).

The monthly property taxes must be the current Municipal billing level.  Get this from the Listing Realtor or Tax Roll.  It should be included on the Broker MLS document.

Many Lenders use set amounts for the monthly Heat requirement.  This amount is based on the square footage of the subject property and is not necessarily the same amount of expense you will pay when living in the home.  This amount is for mortgage qualification purposes only so obtaining the exact heating amounts from the home owner is not necessary.  Please check with your Mortgage Professional.

The Condominium Fees are the current monthly requirement as set by the property Board of Directors.  Get this from the Listing Realtor.  It should be included on the Broker MLS document.

This ratio can be no greater than 35% for applicants with Beacon Scores lower than 680 or 39% for applicant’s with Beacon Scores higher than 680.

Total Debt Service Ratio


The TDS is determined by using the following calculation:

TDS = PITH + Condo Fees + All other monthly obligations / Total Monthly Gross Income
All other monthly obligations include Credit Cards, Car payments, Student Loans, Child or Spousal Support payments, personal loans etc.  It does not include items like cell phones and car or home insurance.

This ratio can be no greater than 39% for applicants with Beacon Scores lower than 680 or 44% for applicants with Beacon Scores higher than 680.

Please note that while the above stated ratio values are industry accepted standards, some Lenders have different ratios to support their products.

Examples


Now that we've defined the framework, let’s look as some examples to see the effect on GDS and TDS.

Example #1
Down payment - $9,250 plus 1.5% for closing costs (approximately $2,800 in this example)

Subject Property - $185,000 Single Family Dwelling 1,165 sq. ft., Property Taxes - $2,000

Current 5-year “A” Interest Rate – 2.89%, 25-year amortization

Applicant #1

Annual Income: $40,000 – Full time regular employment for past 5 years, Credit Score: 674, Visa Balance: $5,200, Car Payment: $325/month, Student Loans: $175/month. For mortgage qualification purposes, 3% of outstanding credit card payments are used.  All other obligations are taken at their contracted monthly rates.  Therefore the total monthly debt payment is $656 for Applicant #1.

Applicant #2

Annual Income: $26,000 – Full time regular employment for past 2 years, Credit Score: 700, Visa Balance: $2,900, Car Payment: $245/month.  Therefore the total monthly debt payment is $332 for Applicant #2.

Crunching the Numbers
Based on this scenario, the GDS calculation would be as follows:

GDS = Principle & Interest + Taxes + Heat (PITH) + Condo Fees (if applicable) / Total Monthly Gross Income

GDS = $847.73 + 166.67 + $85 / $5,500 = 19.99%

Based on this scenario, the TDS calculation would be as follows:

TDS = PITH + Condo Fees + All other monthly obligations / Total Monthly Gross Income

TDS = PITH ($847.73 + 166.67 + $85) + All other monthly obligations ($998) / $5,500 = 38.13%

Therefore, this deal would work as the GDS and TDS maximum ratios for Credit Scores less than 680 of 35% and 42% have not been exceeded.  These applicants are within their level of affordability.

Example #2

Down payment - $175,000 plus 1.5% for closing costs (approximately $6,000 in this example)

Subject Property - $575,000 Single Family Dwelling 3,600 sq. ft., Property Taxes - $6,000

Current 5-year “B” Stated Income Interest Rate – 3.09%, 25-year amortization

Applicant #1

Annual Income: $80,000 – Business owner for past 7 years, Credit Score: 764, Visa Balance: $17,000, Car Payment: $725/month, Child Support Payments for the next eight years: $450/month. For mortgage qualification purposes, 3% of outstanding credit card payments are used.  All other obligations are taken at their contracted monthly rates.  Therefore the total monthly debt payment is $1,685 for Applicant #1.

Applicant #2

Annual Income: $26,000 – Full time regular employment for past 4 years, Credit Score: 700, Visa Balance: $5,900, Car Payment: $560/month.  Therefore the total monthly debt payment is $737 for Applicant #2.

Crunching the Numbers

Based on this scenario, the GDS calculation would be as follows:

GDS = Principle & Interest + Taxes + Heat (PITH) + Condo Fees (if applicable) / Total Monthly Gross Income

GDS = $1,915.62 + 500 + $115 / $8,833 = 28.65%

Based on this scenario, the TDS calculation would be as follows:

TDS = PITH + Condo Fees + All other monthly obligations / Total Monthly Gross Income

TDS = PITH ($1,915.62 + 500 + $115) + All other monthly obligations ($2,422) / $8,833 = 56.07%


Therefore, this deal would NOT work as the GDS and TDS maximum ratios for Credit Scores greater than 680 of 39% and 44% have been exceeded.

While these applicants are within their level of affordability for the GDS (housing) calculation, their additional monthly obligations bring their TDS levels beyond accepted levels for mortgage financing approvals.



No comments:

Post a Comment